Insights

From First Call to Follow-Up: How to Keep Patients From Slipping Through the Cracks

Written By Annabel Veysey

Practical ways to create a seamless patient journey in an era of rising competition from first call to follow-up.

We've all been there. A patient calls, sounds interested, maybe even books a consultation - and then... silence. They don't show up, don't reschedule, and somehow vanish into thin air. Meanwhile, you're left wondering what went wrong and whether there was something more you (or your PA) could have done.

In today's competitive UK healthcare landscape, losing patients between first contact and treatment isn't just frustrating - it's costly. But here's the thing: most of the time, patients aren't deliberately choosing to go elsewhere. They're simply getting lost in the gaps of our own systems.

The good news? Creating a seamless patient journey doesn't require expensive software or a complete system overhaul. Often, it's about tightening up the small details that make all the difference.

Let's start with what the data tells us about the UK market. NHS England has estimated that there are 7.2 million missed general practice appointments annually, at a cost of £216 million. That's just in primary care - but the problem extends well beyond GP surgeries.

Of the 103 million outpatient appointments booked in 2021/22, 7.6% ended in a 'Did Not Attend' (DNA), equating to an average of 650,000 monthly appointment slots. More recent data shows this has increased further: in 2023-24, 8.0 million outpatient appointments were DNAs, an increase of 0.2% from the previous year.

But here's what's encouraging: reminders have been shown to reduce DNAs by up to 80%, and practices implementing systematic approaches are seeing remarkable results. The key is understanding that this isn't just an NHS problem - it's affecting all healthcare providers across the UK.

The landscape has shifted dramatically in recent years. Almost seven in ten people (67%) say that they would consider using private healthcare, with over one third (34%) saying they would pay for treatment in the next 12 months if they needed it. Even more striking, this rises to almost half (44%) of 25-34-year-olds who expect to use private healthcare in the coming year.

A record 4.7 million people were covered by Private Medical Insurance (PMI) through their employer in 2023 - the highest in more than 30 years of data collection. Meanwhile, private admissions in the UK reached their highest ever level for a quarter in Q1 2024, with 238,000 admissions - a 3% increase on the former highest quarter.

This isn't just about insurance-funded care. Paying for treatment is becoming increasingly normalised with almost one third (32%) of people surveyed stating they had previously used private healthcare. The self-pay market is thriving, driven largely by NHS waiting times and patients' desire for faster access to care.

What does this mean for private practices? Competition is intensifying across all healthcare sectors. Patients have more choice than ever before, and they're willing to pay for better experiences.

UK research has identified the most common causes include forgetfulness, difficulty in cancelling appointments, being too ill to attend, work and family commitments, inconvenience, and transportation issues. But there's more to the story.

Patients with a mental health diagnosis, or with multiple or serious physical health conditions were more likely to miss appointments. Additionally, patients were more likely to miss booked appointments if they were of lower socioeconomic status or living in a deprived area, or from a non-white or minority ethnic background.

Royal Cornwall Hospitals NHS Trust found that the 10-20% of their patients from the most deprived backgrounds were most likely to miss an outpatient appointment. This tells us that the patient journey needs to be designed with accessibility and inclusivity in mind.

Importantly, patients have told us that when they miss an appointment, it often stems from difficulties with processes and communication. They also told us they were more likely to miss an appointment if they had a poor experience of attending a healthcare appointment previously.

Based on UK research and what we're seeing in successful practices, there are several make-or-break moments in every patient journey:

The First Contact This is where most patients form their lasting impression. Only 49.7% of patients said they find it easy to contact someone on the phone at their GP practice, with just 18.9% finding it 'very easy'. In the private sector, this represents a massive opportunity to differentiate.

The Booking and Confirmation Process Forward booking time in days is the best predictor of practice DNA rates. The research shows that longer waits between booking and appointment correlate with higher no-show rates. Studies report that including the cost of a potential missed appointment in a message produces a DNA rate of 8.4% compared to 11.1% in a message without this information.

The Pre-Appointment Journey 27.1% of NHS patients had an appointment on the same day they contacted their practice, while 20.8% waited between a week or two. For private practices, this highlights the competitive advantage of responsive scheduling and proactive communication during the waiting period.

The Day of the Appointment 89.9% of NHS patients said that their needs were met at their last appointment, but the remaining 10% represents significant room for improvement. The practices that handle last-minute changes and unexpected delays gracefully are the ones patients remember positively.

See how our clients describe this difference in their own words in our testimonials.

Before we dive into systems and processes, let's talk about the most important investment you can make: a brilliant medical PA. They are quite literally the face of your practice and the thread that weaves the entire patient journey together.

Don't scrimp on this role. A good medical PA doesn't just book appointments - they anticipate problems before they happen, spot the patients who might struggle with their journey, and create the kind of experience that turns first-time patients into lifelong advocates.

I've seen practices transform their patient retention simply by investing in the right PA. They're the ones who remember that Mrs Johnson gets anxious and needs extra reassurance, who spot when Mr Patel's usual appointment pattern changes and proactively reaches out, who can de-escalate a frustrated caller and turn them into a satisfied patient.

A skilled medical PA can grow your patient base in ways that no marketing budget can match. They create the seamless, personal experience that patients talk about to their friends and family. When someone says "I love my practice," they're usually talking about how they were treated by your PA.

This isn't about being nice - though that helps. It's about being strategic, proactive, and understanding that every interaction is an opportunity to exceed expectations. Get this right, and everything else becomes easier.

Discover more about how our Medical PA services can support your practice.

With the right medical PA in place, the research shows us what systems work in the UK healthcare context:

Implement Strategic Reminder Systems Most UK practices that successfully reduced DNAs chose patient behavioural interventions, such as publicising the number of appointments lost to DNAs, SMS reminders, hotline/text cancellation services, or telephone reminders for those with a history of DNAs.

Address Structural Issues, Not Just Patient Behaviour Here's the key insight: one practice instituted a systematic change to the appointment system by reducing the maximum booking time from 1 month to 1 working day and saw significant improvements. To reduce non-attendance, it appears that the appointment system needs to change, not the patient.

Leverage Digital Solutions Strategically A recent study reveals telemedicine visits are less likely to result in a missed appointment compared to in-person appointments. Patients engaged with portals are less likely to miss appointments, with a 39% difference in DNA rates between registered and unregistered patients.

Create Accessibility and Inclusivity Given the demographics of patients most likely to miss appointments, successful practices are implementing short notice lists so that any last-minute cancellations can be used by people who are able to attend without prior warning.

Speedier access to care is the top reason for people choosing to use private healthcare, with over half (54%) of all 18 to 24-year-olds who have used private healthcare previously having done so to access private GP appointments.

This tells us that follow-up isn't just about medical care - it's about maintaining that competitive advantage that brought patients to you in the first place. Whether a patient completes treatment, needs time to consider options, or decides against proceeding, how you handle that follow-up often determines whether they'll return or recommend you to others.

The practices excelling in today's market understand that every interaction is an opportunity to reinforce why patients chose private care over NHS options.

Let's be direct about this: poor patient journey management is expensive. Each missed appointment costs approximately £120 to the NHS, and while private practice costs may differ, the principle remains: every no-show represents lost revenue and wasted resources.

In Cheshire and Merseyside alone, there were nearly 420,000 missed outpatient appointments in 2022-2023. Successful interventions in that region contributed to a reduction in DNA rates from 10% in January 2023 to 8% in April 2023, equating to 10,000 more outpatient appointments being made available.

The UK private healthcare market is experiencing unprecedented growth. Private hospital admissions reached a record 898,000 in 2023 - a 7% increase year-on-year, surpassing pre-pandemic levels. Each quarter in 2024 had a record number of admissions compared to the equivalent period in previous years.

This growth brings opportunity, but also intensified competition. The UK private healthcare market is highly competitive and fragmented, comprising a mix of large hospital groups, independent clinics, specialty providers, and digital health platforms.

The key to thriving in this environment is creating systems that work consistently, regardless of volume fluctuations or staffing changes. Start by focusing on one touchpoint at a time. Get your first contact process absolutely right before moving on to appointment confirmations. Master your pre-appointment communications before tackling follow-up procedures.

To secure a larger market share, it's essential for healthcare providers to innovate, use digital marketing, focus on exceptional patient experiences, and continually adapt to evolving market dynamics.

Remember, patients aren't looking for perfection - they're looking for consistency, professionalism, and the feeling that they matter to your practice. In a market where less than a quarter of the population is willing to pay for private care or insurance, every patient interaction is precious.

The practices that will succeed in this competitive landscape are the ones that view every touchpoint as an opportunity to exceed the expectations that drove patients to choose private healthcare in the first place. The question isn't whether you can afford to invest in improving your patient journey - it's whether you can afford not to in today's rapidly evolving UK healthcare market.


At MPM Virtual, we know the difference the right PA makes, because it’s at the heart of our team’s expertise.